Letter: Town halls won't hurt, but may not be representative
Published: Tuesday, July 22, 2008
10:09 AM EDT
To the Editor:
I am sure that Worthington Board of Education member Mark
Schare does not equate the want of such a luxury/status
symbol as a Lexus with the want of an excellent school
system in a community. Yet, from the story you published
recently (Worthington News, July 9), one might gain that
impression.
Schare used the word affordability to indicate what would be
the acceptable level of any tax increase. However,
affordability is a relationship between availability of
funds and existing priorities, and thus differs for each of
the district's constituencies.
Purchasing a luxury/status symbol car is a discretionary
purchase with little consequence except for the individual,
while the quality of the educational endeavor affects an
entire community in many ways. Mr. Schare wants to have the
community determine what is an acceptable and affordable tax
increase. The community already does this at election time.
Although there is nothing wrong with having community input
by using town hall events, the outcome usually reflects who
attends the meetings, and unless a broad segment of the
community is represented, the outcome will not be
representative. The perspective of parents with children in
school or of those who have moved to the community with
certain expectations for their pre-school children will be
different from that of individuals without children in
school. Even among this latter group, there will be a
division between those who see little value in an excellent
school district and those of us who value such a district as
a community asset.
Past episodes indicate that much of the controversy about
the tax level will center around teacher compensation. Are
teachers compensated too much, too little or just right? It
is important that any discussion be based on how to achieve
the desired level of quality (program diversity/staff
quality) and not on anti-teacher/union positions as have
been expressed in the past by a few very vocal members of
the community.