Letter: Those who decry teacher pay offer no real solutions
Published: Wednesday, November 25,
2009 11:54 AM EST
To the Editor:
Cathleen Sato's opinion of the people behind Educate
Worthington (Worthington News, Nov. 18) is correct, but she
gives them too much credit. They're not as effective as Sato
thinks.
There is reason for that. They can say less in more words
than a fundamentalist preacher.
A reading of John Herrington's guest column (Worthington
News, Nov. 11) and any of Marc Schare's pontifications
reveals the fatal flaw of the Educate Worthington leaders:
They have no solutions to the problems they claim exist. Ask
any of them for a direct answer to what specific changes
should be made and you will not get an answer.
In the late 1990s, I attended a public forum at which
then-school board member Jim Timko stated that Worthington
teachers were overpaid. I then asked him point blank how
much Worthington teachers should be paid. He looked as
though I had just handed him a subpoena and he sheepishly
answered, "I don't know."
Ms. Sato wants to "call them out." The best way to do that
is to pose the question: "How much should Worthington
teachers be paid in salary and benefits?" Any answer other
than specific figures will be an admission that they can't
substantiate their claims. If they know enough to make the
statements they've made, they know enough to give the
specific figures requested.