WORTHINGTON BOARD OF EDUCATION

SCHOOL BOARD VACANCY SUPPLEMENTAL QUESTIONNAIRE

 

 

Candidate’s Name:  ANITA DORAN

 

Contact Address:  7624 INNBROOK PLACE, COLUMBUS, OH 43235

 

Contact Telephone Number: 614/848-8762

 

Contact Email Address:  sadoran@wowway.com

 

Please answer all questions and send a completed questionnaire by January 16 via email to:

 

vgnezda@worthington.k12.oh.us

 

 

1. Please state your professional or volunteer activities with K-12 education, either in the Worthington School District, another school district or in a private school.

 

Volunteer Activities @ Worthington Hills Elementary School (WHES):

Artworks Committee (9 years, 7 years as Co-Chair)

Book Fair volunteer (9 years)

Bulletin Board Chair (3 years)

Cafeteria volunteer (9 years)

Classroom Representative (4 years)

Family Fun Committee (6 years)

Library Aide (4 years)

Market Day volunteer (3 years)

Musical Scenery Committee (6 years)

PTA member (9 years)

PTA Bylaw Revision Co-Chair (2 years)

PTA Council (1 year)

Science Committee (6 years, 2 years as Co-Chair)

SWEPP  Member (6 years)

Weekly Messenger (2 years)

 

Volunteer Activities @ McCord Middle School (MMS):

Awards volunteer (1 year)

Book Fair volunteer (3 years)

Boys Sports Concession Co-Chair (1 year)

Cross Country & Track volunteer (2 years)

Canteen Chaperone (3 years)

Library Aide (2 years)

PTA member (3 years)

PTA Council (1 year)

SWEPP Member (1 year)

 

Volunteer Activities @ Worthington Kilbourne High School:

Activity Club, including Freshman Day, Wolves for Cubs, Adopt-a-Family (1 year)

Band Boosters volunteer (2 years)

PTA member (2 years)

 

2.  What personal traits, skills, or experiences would you bring to the position that you feel would make you an effective board member?

 

            I would be an effective member of the Worthington School Board of Education (the “Board”) because I am a good listener, a quick learner, work well with others, and have good sense of humor which I suspect will be important at some Board meetings.   My legal training and work experience as a contract/fraud attorney at the Defense Supply Center Columbus involved advising, problem solving and fact-gathering – all skills that I can draw upon to be an effective board member.   In addition, my volunteer experience in all levels of Worthington School District (the “District”) has allowed me to gain an extensive knowledge of how our schools operate, a good network of contacts within the District and the community, and how the students in our district are performing. 

 

3.  What do you think is the most pressing issue in the Worthington Schools?

 

The most pressing issue is clearly fiscal stability.  During the ten years that I have resided in the district, the Board has been increasingly forced to deal with declining revenues, and numerous state and federal mandates over which it has little power to foresee or control.  It has presented at least four levy issues in the past ten years to balance the District’s budget, and each time, these requests for more money have been more and more skeptically received by the community.   A lot of this skepticism based on the belief that the District is wasting or has wasted money in the past.  Over the last several years though, I think the Board and the administration has made difficult decisions and made substantial cuts to its budget which have better positioned the District for financial stability. 

Despite these budget reductions, I foresee that financial stability will continue to be a problem.   The complexity and changing nature of Ohio’s funding formulas and tax frameworks that force the District to return levies to the ballot every two or three years.  in addition, state and federal educational mandates, such as the Ohio Graduation Test, the new Ohio Core Curriculum, and the federal No Child Left Behind Act impose new standards, requirements, testing and sanctions, without fully funding their costs.   These costs further diminish financial control by the Board over the District’s budget.  I intend to do what I can as a Board member to draw attention to these costs and its impact on the District so that community better understands the causes of the District’s fiscal issue. 

 

4.  If it were necessary to make substantial cuts in the expenditures of the district, what areas would you cut first, and what areas would you seek to preserve?

 

Without figures specifying the expenditures for each budget item, nor the size of the budget reduction need, I cannot answer this question fully.   I can explain how I would approach the problem.    

Obviously, the Board has to preserve budget amounts for those budget items mandated by law, such as providing and meeting Individual Education Plans.  After that,  I would identify potential cuts by looking at areas would have the least amount of direct impact on the student’s educational experience including class sizes, depth of curriculum, fine arts, and sports.  I would explore other potential revenue sources in lieu of cuts, for example improving operational efficiencies.  I would also look for creative ways to cuts costs, such as the District’s recent change to health savings accounts. 

I believe that input from District staff, especially teachers, and the community is critical in determining what budget reductions should be made.   In fact, over the past week, I have asked my friends and neighbors about areas they thought could be cut, and they had several suggestions including reducing   transportation costs, especially at the high school level, reducing maintenance costs at our facilities, and further cuts to administrative staff.  I would investigate these types of suggestions as potential areas to cut.   Only as a last resort, would I want to consider closing a building. 

 

As to areas I would seek to preserve, I feel that we have to maintain our quality education and the unique educational opportunities it provides.  Worthington Schools are known for its strong schools.  The strength of our school district enhances our community, as well as our property values.   We cannot have quality education without quality teachers.  Therefore, a competitive salary for teachers is absolutely necessary to attract and retain the high caliber of teachers we want.  I would also preserve the neighborhood format of our schools to the greatest extent possible. 

 

5. If it were possible to add new programs to the district, what programs would you seek to add?

 

At the elementary school level, I would add a foreign language program as many studies have shown that young students grasp new languages more easily than older ones.  In middle school, I would additional gifted services, such as an advanced science class, and a keyboarding class to better prepare them for High School and College.   At high school, I think it would be appropriate to add a standardized test preparation class in light of the current state and federal testing requirements, as well as the ACT/SAT tests.

 

6.  What do you see as the impact of   “No Child Left Behind” on the Worthington Schools? What about the Ohio Core legislation?

 

            The No Child Left Behind Act (the “NCLB”) mandates that states eliminate the academic "achievement gap" which exists between different groups of students, paying particular attention to the progress of students who historically have not been well served.  

This is a laudable goal, but has negatively impacted the Worthington School District both academically and financially.   Academically, the NCLB has significantly impacted the Worthington Schools.  It requires increased focus on math, reading and science so that students are prepared for the annual testing.  I am concerned that these assessment requirements devaluing of non-tested subjects like social studies, music, and art.  Additionally, I believe that the NCLB’s “one-size-fits-all” annual testing as a yardstick for progress is a disservice to teachers and students alike.  Financially, it is an under-funded mandate.   The administrative costs of complying with the NCLB, training staff, administering the tests annually, are an additional burden on the District’s budget.   Neither the state, nor the federal government has provided enough funds to address these costs.  The upside is that Wrothington Schools have been meeting the “annual yearly progress” requirements, and have not suffered any of the sanctions provided for by the NCLB. 

 

I believe the impact of the recently passed Ohio Core Curriculum (the “OCC”) to the District in significant ways, but not as overwhelmingly as the NCLB has.   There will be additional costs, again largely unfunded, passed on to the schools to establishing the additional curriculum requirements for all students.  As I expect that the majority of Worthington high school students already follow the course load recommended for application to four year degree colleges which meets the OCC with the addition of one math credit and 3 science credits with labs,  the OCC’s impact on Worthington School might not be as great as on other districts with less students continuing on to college.  At the same time, not all Worthington students have followed this path in the past, so we may need to add math and science teachers to comply with the OCC which would be a significant burden.   It is difficult to quantify these costs so soon after passage of the legislation, but there will certainly be additional costs incurred due to the OCC’s notification and assessment requirements, as well as the administrative costs to ensure that the district complies with the OCC.

In addition to the financial burden on the school district, I am concerned that this standardized curriculum is too rigid to meet the needs of all Worthington students.   The OCC also adds yet another assessment requirement in addition to the Ohio Graduation Test already mandated, and the ACT or SAT that college bound students already take.  

Notwithstanding the above criticism of the NCLB and OCC, I understand that as a Board member I am obligated to uphold the law and ensure that the District is operating within the bounds of the law.  As a lawyer, I understand the importance of these obligations.  

7.  If selected, what do you see as your role in influencing state education laws and policies that affect the Worthington Schools?

 

I plan to have an active role as an advocate for the District as I believe the Ohio Legislature has negatively impacted schools in general, and our District, in particular by over-regulating curriculum, imposing unfunded testing requirements and failing to adequately address the “phantom revenue” issue.   I believe that these legislative actions have resulted in diminished local control of the school districts.  To the extent permitted by law and agreed to by the Board, I would advocate for change in these areas. 

 

8.  What do you see as the roles and responsibilities of a school board member?

 

The roles and responsibilities of a Worthington School Board Member are clearly spelled out in its job description:  

 

“Description: Employs and evaluates the district superintendent and treasurer; establishes

policies to govern and give guidance by which the district will function; evaluate

and, if appropriate, approve administrative regulations which carry out board

policy; through positive public relations, promote educational issues in the

district.”

 

Numerous “Essential Functions” are also listed in the job description, but are “not ranked in order of importance.”  So to further answer this question, I would rank the following “Essential Functions” as most important:

 

  1. Evaluate whether the schools effectively achieve the board’s educational purposes
  2. Determine and approve the annual budget and appropriations for the district
  3. Inform the public about the district’s progress and needs; solicit public opinion as it affects the district.

 

Additionally, it is clear to me that parental and community involvement in schools is an essential component of a strong and effective school district, and I would work to encourage increased involvement. 

 

9.  What evidence do you believe shows the Worthington Schools are adequately, or inadequately, preparing students for their lives after graduation? 

 

In talking with Worthington students, especially at the high school level, I am consistently impressed with their academic accomplishments, communication skills, and their interest in a variety of subjects including music, sports, and theater.   Many also pour their energy into community service through clubs and activities.  All of these qualities are evidence to me that Worthington Schools prepares it students well for healthy and productive lives.